Why doesn’t Jupiter have rings like Saturn?

Giant moons prevent giant ice ring formations

Jupiter and a few of its moons with a faint ring seen. Credit score: NASA/ESA/CSA/B. Holler/J. Stansberry/STScI

As a result of it’s bigger, Jupiter ought to have bigger and extra spectacular rings than Saturn does. However new analysis from UC Riverside exhibits that Jupiter’s huge moons forestall that view from lighting up the night time sky.

“It has lengthy bothered me why Jupiter would not have much more wonderful rings that might put Saturn’s to disgrace,” mentioned UCR astrophysicist Stephen Kane, who led the analysis.

“If Jupiter had them, they would seem even brighter to us, as a result of the planet is far nearer than Saturn.” Kane additionally had questions on whether or not Jupiter ever had improbable rings and misplaced them. it’s doable for ring buildings be short-term.

To grasp why Jupiter seems to be the best way it does at the moment, Kane and his graduate pupil Zhexing Li ran a dynamic pc simulation that defined the orbits of Jupiter’s 4 main moons, in addition to the orbit of the planet itself and details about Jupiter. the time it takes for the rings to type. Their outcomes at the moment are on-line, and can quickly be revealed within the planetary science day by day.

Saturn’s rings are made largely of ice, a few of which can have come from comets, that are additionally made largely of ice. If the moons are huge sufficient, their gravity can pull ice out of a planet’s orbit, or change the ice’s orbit sufficient that it collides with the moons.

“We discovered that Jupiter’s Galilean moons, one in all which is the biggest moon in our photo voltaic system, would in a short time destroy any massive rings that may type,” Kane mentioned. Because of this, it’s unlikely that Jupiter had massive rings at any time in its previous.

“Huge planets type huge moons, which prevents them from having substantial rings,” Kane mentioned.

Giant moons prevent giant ice ring formations

The Galilean moons of Jupiter. Credit score: NASA

The 4 of them large planets in our Photo voltaic systemโ€”Saturn, Neptune, Uranus, and in addition Jupiterโ€”they really have rings. Nevertheless, each Neptune’s and Jupiter’s rings are so faint that they’re tough to see with conventional stargazing devices.

Coincidentally, a few of the latest photographs from the newly commissioned James Webb Area Telescope included photographs of Jupiter, by which the faint rings are seen.

“We did not know these short-lived rings existed till the Voyager spacecraft handed by as a result of we could not see them,” Kane mentioned.

Uranus has rings that aren’t as massive however are extra substantial than Saturn’s. Sooner or later, Kane intends to run simulations of circumstances on Uranus to see what the lifespan of that planet’s rings may be.

Some astronomers He believes that Uranus is turned on its aspect because of a collision that the planet had with one other celestial physique. Their rings could possibly be the stays of that impression.

Past their magnificence, the rings assist astronomers perceive a planet’s historical past, as a result of they provide proof of collisions with moons or comets that will have occurred previously. The form and dimension of the rings, in addition to the composition of the fabric, provide a sign of the kind of occasion that fashioned them.

“For us astronomers, it is the blood spatter on the partitions of against the law scene. Once we take a look at the rings of giants planetsit is proof that one thing catastrophic occurred to place that materials there,” Kane mentioned.


Uranus and Neptune’s rings might assist map their interiors


Extra data:
Stephen R. Kane, Zhexing Li, The Dynamic Feasibility of an Prolonged Jupiter Ring System. arXiv:2207.06434v2 [astro-ph.EP], arxiv.org/abs/2207.06434

Quotation: Why Jupiter Would not Have Rings Like Saturn (July 21, 2022) Retrieved July 21, 2022 from https://phys.org/information/2022-07-jupiter-doesnt-saturn.html

This doc is topic to copyright. Aside from any honest dealing for personal examine or analysis functions, no half could also be reproduced with out written permission. The content material is offered for informational functions solely.

Leave a Comment